Petitioning Against Reality

Posted on by xiphoidmaneuver and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

A petition is ostensibly a show of mass support for a course of action someone else is supposed to take.

In practice they are often used to make a statement more so than to catalyze action. Generally though a petition is dressed up to appear as a request or demand for action.

This petition doesn’t have the usual dressing. The tagline ‘Tell Obama “I told you so” by signing the petition below!’ really lays it out.

A signatory gets to stick it to the man and tell Obama “I told you so – My perspective was correct and I hold you in contempt”. In the process they commit themselves to the text of the petition – they have committed themselves to the belief/rhetoric that S&P warned of a downgrade unless there was a $4 trillion budget cut. This is unreal: S&P warned of a downgrade unless the projected growth of spending minus projected growth of taxation over ten years decreased by $4 trillion. Both Obama and House Republicans produced S&P approvable plans to avoid downgrade that the other party rejected. Neither produced a plan to actually cut spending by $4 trillion from current spending levels.

What happens when you are confronted by reality but you have already signed a petition against it? 

Related posts:

  1. Credit Ratings, Market Crashes, and the Cover Story
  2. Framing Deficit Debates
  3. There are no Americans in Baghdad
  4. Warren Buffett wants to be taxed on this, so you won’t tax him on that.

One Response to Petitioning Against Reality

  1. max says:

    What happens when you are confronted by reality but you have already signed a petition against it?

    You change your name to Grover Norquist.

Leave a Reply